Proxxon Micromot KT 150 and Proxxon BFB 2000 vs Wabeco Drilling Milling stand and compound table

I've trying to choose between these two, so I thought I'd make some notes:
ProxxonWabeco
Total cost£320.00£254.00
Column thickness4535
Stand Weight713.5
Table weight4.95.7
Width200400
Depth200180
Height500500
Z Travel65250
X Travel150320
Y Travel150100
T-Slot size1010
Fine feedyesno

The Wabeco stand is heavier, and this is generally a good sign. The set up is also cheaper, and includes a step clamp set. The prices include shipping. The Wabeco stand has an integral Y-Axis, which makes it more flexible. E.g. it could be used with a router, which would tend to be too wide to fit in the Proxxon.

The Proxxon components are widely used and reviewed: they are a known quantity. The column thickness, which should be the most important statistic when it comes to accuracy, is significantly greater. It can definitely be converted to CNC.  It's smaller size means it fits better in my work space. It has a Z axis fine feed. Some routers would fit it. The table comes with a fence. Definitely useful for routing.

The absence of the Z-axis fine feed on the Wabeco might mean precise milling is very difficult. The Wabeco Milling table looks thin and flimsy compared to the Proxxon. In fact the two tables weigh about the same, despite the Wabeco table having a much larger area. The Wabeco might suffer from the same clamping distortion of Proxxons KT 70.

Popular posts from this blog

3D Printer ramblings

 I have a Prusa i3 mk2.5 in storage. I used to use it in my shed I used not to worry about it's harmful emissions: I just didn't share the space with it. I had, however, added an enclosure, and was planning to add a HEPA filter too it. Once it's in an enclosure, it's massive. Even if I had added the filter, there's no where to put it. I'd like a small printer that has an enclosure or is easy to enclose. I figure I could get by with 150x150x150 build area: I was rarely patient enough to wait for my i3 to print bigger models. 200x200x200 would probably actually replace my current printer, so that would be a bonus. Not many printers have HEPA filters, which is really a shame. It seems just to be the result of a misconception about HEPA filters, and about filtration in general. Read this . E.g. I was looking at a used Lulzbot mini, and there are ready made enclosure s for it, however . In this particular case, it's no big deal: opportunities to buy a Lulzbot min
Read more

Balance Bot V2

Image
My current balance bot sort of works, but it's surprising it does: it's centre of gravity is actually only about 60mm above the motor axis. The whole thing ways 320g. The 6 AAA batteries only weigh 70g, so despite being right at the top, the don't affect the centre of gravity much. 6 AA batteries would weigh about 180g. That would add a 34% to the overall weight, and move the centre of gravity much higher. Seems like a dramatic increase in weight: it would be nice to be a bit more incremental. More AAA batteries isn't really worth considering: they only weight 12g, vs 30g for an AA. 4 AA would deliver much less power/torque, so that's no good. There's no middle ground, in other words. I'm also going to make the whole thing a bit taller: I need more space to add more sensors in any case. Last time I made the frame, I needed an elaborate jig to get it square and it actually didn't work that well. This time, I decided to use some short bits of a
Read more

Robot arm

Image
I 3d printed this robot arm I original found on Thingiverse, but the Instructable is recommended. There's a MK2, and also a delta style arm, both of which look like good alternatives, but this will do for now. Here's a video of it moving: I've attached it to an STM32F4 Nucleo board, via a prototype shield: In the video, I'm sending commands from a python script that runs on my desktop, communicating via USB serial. I've written an implementation of canonical s-expressions in c++ that doesn't require memory allocation, as well as a python version to talk to it. It's the main reason I haven't posted for so long, and of course overkill for just controlling some servos, but should prove more generally useful. Here's the code . It uses platformio for the build, and mbed rtos.
Read more